Friday, June 26, 2009
Appendectomy
Regardless, I still went to the party with the other YAVs and Debbie on Monday night. The entire evening, I had been having bad stomach pains. As I was waiting for a bus to take me back to my host family's house after the party, my stomach was hurting worse than it had been all night. Upon seeing how full the busses were and realizing that I would probably have to stand up in a crowded bus for the hour-plus long ride back home, I decided to instead see if I could spend the night in Debbie's apartment instead of going all the way back to Comas.
Debbie and her husband Harry, being wonderful people/an extraordinary YAV site coordinator couple, of course let me spend the night in the guest bedroom of their apartment. We all figured I either had a stomach virus or had eaten something undercooked. Before I went to bed, Debbie off-handedly asked me if I still had my appendix. I said yes, but that I doubted my appendix was causing the problem because the pain was in the center of my stomach and not on the right side, where the appendix is located.
However, when I woke up at 3am, the pain had definitely all moved to my lower right side. Concerned and unable to sleep, I used Debbie's internet to look up signs and symptoms of appendicitis on Web MD. I basically had all of them (chiefly, stomach pain that starts generally in the center abdominal region and then slowly becomes acute and concentrated in the lower right side), and the web site said that appendicitis, if not treated quickly, can cause the appendix to rupture, which is a medical emergency. So I knocked on Debbie and Harry's door at about 3:30am, asking them to take me to the hospital.
The Stella Maris clinic is one of the best hospitals in Lima, and is probably less than 1/2 mile from Debbie and Harry's apartment. After being given a physical examination, blood tests, x-rays and an ultrasound, they confirmed the appendicitis and the need to operate. The laparoscopic operation was performed by a surgeon who also performs organ transplants. The operation was over and I was awake and talking by mid-day Tuesday, and discharged from the hospital at about mid-day Thursday.
*************************************************
Calling this year of service in Peru a year of "firsts" would be a gross understatement. I had never even had an IV in before this year. Aside from my wisdom teeth being removed, I had never had surgery and had never spent the night in the hospital. This probably explains why I was a lot calmer during the whole ordeal than a lot of people were. (Debbie kept giving me updates about how people here in Peru were reacting when she told them the news. I did get a chance to talk to my mom before the surgery - she seemed a whole lot more nervous than I was, but I had never had surgery in ANY country before, so I didn't know what to be scared of).
At this point, I simply have a lot to thank God for. I could have very easily been on a bus to Huancayo Monday night instead of safe and sound in Debbie and Harry's apartment. Or I could have been at home in Comas, where I would probably have been taken to a much different hospital. And if Debbie hadn't asked me about my appendix that night before I went to bed, I probably wouldn't have even considered appendicitis to be a possibility for the cause of my stomach pain.
I feel very lucky and blessed to have so many visitors in the hospital - the other YAVs, Debbie and Harry (who I'm still staying with for a couple days before I go back to my host family), my host family and a few people from both Santa Isabel and Km 13 churches. The time I've spent in the hospital really is like a perfect snapshot of my mission year as a YAV. Thanks to the wonderful people, family, community, fellow YAVs and churches here in Lima, I've "received" and "been served" so much more than I myself could ever possibly give" or "serve."
Wednesday, June 10, 2009
I can't sleep, so instead I'll write about distancing myself from postmodern "white" culture, and eventually upset some of my more liberal friends
I really love the website www.stuffwhitepeoplelike.com. I’m sure most of you have probably heard of it. If for some reason you haven’t, it’s a blog that satirizes and pokes fun of “postmodern,” “hipster,” “liberal elitist” culture from an insider perspective. Stuff white people like is so cool because it basically essentializes and stereotypes the type of (mainly) white people who tend to pride themselves on their uniqueness and inability to be stereotyped (like me and probably most people who read my blog). The list of “Stuff white people like” includes things like “non-profit organizations,” “apple products,” “[correcting other people’s] grammar,” “not owning a television,” “arts degrees,” “Honda Prius,” “yoga” and “having multi-lingual children.” Yep, it’s THAT type of white people. Among the commentary I’ve seen about the site is the observation that it could also be called “Cultural Profile of the
Though I first came across the site last year, during my final semester at Trinity and thought it was hilarious and extremely clever, I didn’t REALLY appreciate its brilliance until I left my college environment (where I was totally surrounded by other “white” people) and came to Peru, where I’m now a minority. While you could probably come up with dozens of “grand narratives” (one of the postmodern-est of postmodern terms) to describe what exactly “Stuff White People Like” boils down to, for me it can be summarized by "modestly" and covertly asserting an aura of superiority over other "white people" and other cultural perspectives by demonstrating how varied and unique your tastes are and by how understanding and inclusive you are towards worldviews that are different from your own.
The thing about the YAV program is that it scores HUGE points within the ranking system of self-worth in “white culture”. Think about it: due to our unique, progressive religious/spiritual perspectives, as YAVs we make the decision after graduating college to go to a foreign country where we live and work among “the poor” in a non-judgmental way, meanwhile rejecting the materialism and technological comforts of
But like it or not, I’ve learned that (where I’m living and working at least) poverty and foreign cultures aren’t so easily romanticized. I’m not living in a mud hut. Most of my friends and acquaintances have plenty to eat. They don’t feel persecuted. They’re not victims of horrible human rights abuses. Although Peru’s two decade period of terrorism and war ended rather recently (within the past 10 years), and although violence broke out between police and indigenous people in one of Peru’s remote mountainous areas as recently as just last week, the people here in Lima don’t seem to have much more fear of war or terrorism than we do in the US. Some of the church members with whom I worship and even a couple of kids in the compassion program talk about the need to help the poor and hungry – in
But my cultural “letdown” goes deeper than that. If I were to bring home some of the “traditional” music that I hear here in
And let's not forget religious beliefs. Talking about the culture in which I live here in Lima becomes even more difficult when you consider the particular flavor of Christianity practiced by the churches where I work. Ask them if they believe that abortion is definitely murder. Ask them if they believe homosexuals should be ordained. Ask them if they think people who don't believe in Jesus as Lord will go to Hell. Ask them if they believe the Bible doesn't contain a single factual error. I don't think I (or most "white people") would agree with their answers.
So what has been disturbing me most about all these characteristics of the culture in which I've been living for the past 9 months? I've realized that in my mind, the only reason that they're "acceptable" is because the people living within the culture speak Spanish, not English, live in Peru, not the US and are brown, not white. Think about it. Taken together, all of these "tastes" - in music, clothing, food, religion etc. - form a perfect cultural profile of the "wrong type" of white person. Let me explain. For the most part, I've been very accepting of the "foreign culture" that I've been living in for the past 9 months. I'm living on the other side of the world and speaking a new language, so I recognize that I see everything with biased, foreign eyes. I know that I am in no place to judge them or educate them about the social/global implications of their lifestyles. Yet, even though I have never before admitted it, in my mind I am VERY quick to either judge or try to "educate" white North Americans that have the exact same tastes -- listen to "corporate" pop music, wear corporate, name brand clothes, love eating at corporate sit-down restaurants and practice a "closed-minded" form of Christianity. The difference is, I can relate much better to the white North Americans who do it. I assume they either don't understand that choosing to support multi-national corporate clothing/food/music companies contributes to global economic inequality and social hegemony (in which case I attempt to "educate" them) or I assume that they DO understand it but choose to support the corporate entities anyway (in which case I judge them).
When I think about the situation I find myself in, and how I ended up in it, the whole thing is quite absurd. I became a YAV to go searching for a new perspective on life and to be challenged by living in a way that was uncomfortable and different from what I'm used to. What I ended up with was quite possibly the opposite of what I expected and yet exactly fits the description of that objective. (Let me pause for a second to say that I don't want to come off as too "negative" -- there are definitely some unique cultural things I've experienced in Lima that you could hardly ever find anywhere in the US, and I've written about them here, and here and here, and here for example.) In many ways, I've ended up living immersed in culture characteristics that my entire worldview beforehand was predicated on changing or defying.
But the thing is, many of the people here in Lima that subscribe to these cultural characteristics are my friends. I've gotten to know them. They are wonderful people. In this sense, the YAV program has succeeded beautifully. The reason I haven't judged (until now, I guess) or criticized the culture of the people I work and live with is because I didn't immediately apply the cultural, political and religious "litmus tests" that I now realize I'm guilty of applying to people in the US.
So where do I go from here? How do I reconcile not wanting to judge or try to change the characteristics of a "foreign culture" with the fact that all of my understanding points to these characteristics as being potentially hegemonic and damaging if they continue? The way I see it, there are basically two options (once you read them, that statement in itself actually gives you a pretty huge clue as to which one I'll pick).
1.) I could use the fact that my friends in Lima are good, loving children of God to rationalize the idea that their views and lifestyle choices are okay. But in the process, I would basically sacrifice my own ideals about the way I believe God wants us to live by implying that they are negotiable and need not apply to everyone.
OR
2.) I could assert that my views on the way we should live (in terms of religious inclusion/open-mindedness and responsible consumer habits) really aren't negotiable; they're important and they can only be effective if as many people as possible subscribe to them. But in the process, I would be implying that my enlightened, educated lifestyle is "better" than the lifestyle habits of my friends in Peru, meaning that I think they should change their lives. This sacrifices my postmodern ideal of not believing one way of life is superior to another.
The oft-noted paradox of post-modernism is that declaring that there is no objective "truth" or "grand-narrative" is in itself an assertion of truth and a grand-narrative. Stuff White People Like and much of what I wrote during the first part of this blog entry proves that even though we don't want to, we white postmoderns do in fact see the world more in "black and white" and "good and evil" than we let on. If we declare that we want to be able to understand everyone's perspective under the premise that "everything is relative" and "truth depends on your worldview," then we are fundamentally at odds with people who believe that truth is concrete/objective/absolute. "Everything is relative" is an absolute statement.
The whole conundrum makes me think of something I've said before and believe in very strongly about faith. The presence of faith implies doubt. Without doubt, what you have isn't faith, but knowledge. Faith can't be proven. Knowledge can. My views concerning Christianity, economics, lifestyle habits etc haven't been proven to be any better than those of my friends and partners in mission in Lima, or anyone elses for that matter. Based on what I've learned through my own life experiences, I BELIEVE they are the best way to live, but I don't KNOW that. One of the first people to make this observation about the relationship between faith and doubt was Soren Kierkegaard, who postmoderns happen to LOVE -- he is sometimes seen as a kind of "forefather" of postmodern theology. But there is a major difference between Kierkegaard's perspective and a true postmodern one. Both perspectives put heavy importance on the presence of doubt/uncertainty. But while a real postmodern loves just mulling over and exploring all of the doubt and trying on all of the different perspectives, Kierkegaard asserts that we have to pick a perspective and stick with it. It's an either/or choice. True postmoderns relish doubt and use it to keep from having to take a definite position. Kierkegaard, on the other hand insists that we have to take a "leap of faith" and make our stand IN SPITE of there being doubt. Once you choose, you don't go back. Although it's risky and has led the church and Christendom to commit many egregious errors and injustices in the past, I believe this is what God demands Christians to do.
In conclusion, don't worry, I'm not going to go on a tirade against materialism, consumerism, corporations and ultra-conservative theology to my friends here in Lima. I will continue to love them and continue to struggle with the implications of the "superiority complex" I've realized that I have. Believe it or not "white culture" is gaining awareness here too. It is not totally culturally insensitive to advocate for my dearly held ideals of supporting local businesses and exploring non-traditional interpretations of scripture. Let me know if you have any questions or suggestions, or if I've said anything terribly offensive (I'm sure I have). I do believe that in general, the postmodern perspective is a valid, important one, and it continues to inform my beliefs. However, I've stopped lying to myself and finally admitted that I really do think the world would be better off if everybody thought like me... which, come to think of it, is probably something so basic and intuitive that it goes without saying for most level-headed people. So maybe I've been writing for 4 hours for nothing. Oh well.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Disclaimer: This last paragraph is probably unnecessary, and shouldn't be taken too seriously.
Ironically enough, by self-righteously deciding to expose the hypocrisy of white culture -- its tendencies toward conformity and self-righteousness/superiority while being entirely predicated on non conformity, uncertainty and humility -- I've thus basically declared myself as superior to it and tried really hard to be a true non-conformist. In glorious postmodern fashion, I have adopted a new worldview that is truly "unique." I've withdrawn from the unspoken contest to see who's the best at using an anti-racist, anti-corporate, anti-materialistic lifestyle to show it's wrong to think that your culture is the best. And by doing so, I've won.
Friday, May 29, 2009
New Newsletter!!
Sunday, May 24, 2009
Birthday weekend
The next day, I went to work at Km 13's compassion program. After work, there was a small "party" in the office that was very similar to the one from the night before. More cake. More singing. More reflecting on the year and being thankful for the community that I've become a part of. Afterwards, Alison, one of the young adult members of Km 13's congregation who also occasionally volunteers with Compassion invited me to have a lonche (small snack-type meal eaten at about 6pm, between lunch and dinner) at her house with her mother and sister. So I went straight after the office part to spend time with Alison and her family. I carried the leftover cake from the party with me and offered it to their family. Thankfully, they accepted (I definitely love cake, but by then I was looking for ways to "share" it). I continue to be amazed by the hospitality that people in Lima have offered me.
Saturday offered me a reprieve of cake. I spent most of the day with youth and young adults from Kilometer 11 church. KM 11 is another church in the Presbytery of Northeastern Lima. I've gotten to know Priscila, the president of their jovenes (youth and young adults) group, from various presbytery events. She had invited me a couple of weeks ago to spend this particular saturday with the Km 11 jovenes, hoping that I could present a theme/message/reflection at the worship service that night. I told her that I could spend the morning and afternoon hanging out with them, but that evening I was already committed to helping out with the worship service/meeting for Km. 13's adolescentes (middle school-age youth) group. She told me that was fine, and arrived to meet me in my neighborhood to together to Km 11 church at about 10am. On the bus ride there, she asked me if I could lead a talk with the jovenes group about ways they can affect change in their communities/country/world.
I've gotten used to these sorts of last-minute-requests for speaking engagements. They seem to be pretty common in the world of the IEP (Evangelical Church of Peru denomination). Pastors are expected to be knowledgeable enough about the Bible to give a sermon or bible study on a moment's notice. And from what I can tell, a large percentage of them really are. And I guess since I also have a University degree (and carry the esteemed title of "missionary"), I'm also expected to be capable of speaking in public about a wide array of topics without previous preparation. On the one hand, it makes me feel really good about my Spanish skills that people who have spent ample time talking with me think that I speak well enough to coherently impart useful information to a large group of people while speaking extemporaneously. On the other hand, I sometimes feel guilty that I can't possibly be living up to their expectations when everything is said and done.
As I'm sure most of you know well, I'm generally a pretty outgoing, fearless, and "just say yes" type of guy when it comes to opportunities to talk in front of people or be the center of attention. Nevertheless, there have been many instances during my time in Peru when I've told people in these situations "I'm sorry, I can't give that [talk, sermon, reflection, etc]. I'm really not prepared or knowledgeable enough right now." However, this particular time, I told Priscila "yes," because doing social/community work from a Christian perspective is kind of what I'm all about.
When we arrived at the church, I got a chance to meet all of the jovenes (and adolescentes, too actually) in the Km 11 church group. Purely for curiosity's sake, one of them asked me when my birthday was. When they found out it was just two days earlier, of course they all sang happy birthday to me (and apologized for not having cake). Then I got to lead my talk. Without missing a beat, I started by reading Isaiah 58, which is a passage in the Bible about "True Fasting" -- which isn't giving up food and praying to God, but instead working to make sure the hungry are fed and "loosing the chains of injustice." (Presbyterians never carry Bibles around with them. Members of the Evangelical Church of Peru, however, do; I've changed my ways.) I then basically "borrowed" much of the central message of David Lamotte's "World Changing 101" seminars to explain why activism and volunteer work is important on both community and global levels. ("There's a difference between changing the world and fixing the world. No one expects you to "fix" the world, but you can't be in the world without changing it in some way. The question is: What type of changes/impact will you make?") Then I simply asked them to list some of the problems they see in their community so we could brainstorm together ways to address them.
The most common answer was gangs. After carefully opining (as a "professional sociologist") on some of the root causes of gangs (poverty, teenage kids in search of identity, lack of other constructive social outlets/activities/groups), we discussed what the church could do to address the issue. We basically came to the conclusion of having Saturday neighborhood clean-up days. There are several artists in the group, so they decided it would be fun to paint over gang graffiti and blank/unsightly walls with Christian pictures/images. They also decided to help clean up trash around some of the streets and fulbito ("mini soccer") courts in an effort to take pride in their neighborhood and convince the other residents to do likewise. All in all, it wasn't anything revolutionary, but I still really enjoyed participating in the conversation and being a part of a group with goals and a plan to improve the problems in their neighborhood. After the talk was over, we all played some fulbito, ate lunch, and then visited the homes of some of the members of the jovenes group who hadn't been attending the worship services recently. I then left to go to the worship service of the Km 13 adolescentes. (Yes, they sang happy birthday to me).
Finally, today I preached at the sunday morning worship service for Km. 13's congregation (a pretty decent sermon about forgiveness, if I do say so myself). And afterwards... you guessed it. More singing. More cake. Pastor Hernando and Ramon (Director of Compassion at Km 13) both shared some very kind words about the work I had been doing with the church. Someone had also put together a slide show featuring pictures from my blog and picasa site (I haven't shared the address with anyone in Peru, but it wouldn't be hard to find -- there's a link to it on the Presbytery's blog and website). And finally, I also got another chance to express my gratitude for the friends I've made and hospitality I've experienced while in Peru.
Tuesday, May 19, 2009
Monday, May 18, 2009
This is not a joke
My mistake was that I looked at the survey before I answered the question about participating in or leading the lecture/activity. On the survey, I immediately identified several questions that were unclear, others that didn't give appropriate answer options, and more still that were worded in a leading manner. After looking it over, as a college grad who's taken more than a couple statistics and research methods classes, I DEFINITELY felt qualified to give them suggestions to improve their survey's clarity and effectiveness. This confidence boost also led me to tell him, in what must have been some sort of stupor, "yes, I can give a talk about a family issue from a sociological perspective. How 'bout I talk about teenage sex and its side effects?"
Fast-forward to today (all of that happened two or three weeks ago). This lecture definitely IS going to happen (frequently, ideas like this "hatch" in a hurry, and then the enthusiasm fizzles). However, because of the lack of communication and maybe my own misunderstanding of some things, the topic has changed a little bit. I went to a Mission & Evangelism committee meeting last Friday and was shown one of two hundred copies of a promotional flyer. Half the flyer has all of the information about the event: "Saturday, May 30, 4pm at Santa Isabel Church [address] a video presentation, followed by a lecture by North American Missionary Alex Cornell (Sociologist) from Trinity University in San Antonio, Texas on the topic of 'Sex Outside of Marriage and Abortion.' Entrance is FREE." The other half has a big, fat picture of me. As of this morning, these flyers are now posted on walls and telephone poles around the neighborhood.
Yes, I really am not sure when "abortion" got added to the lecture topic. I know next to nothing about abortion. If any of you know the secret number to Obama's blackberry, I'd love to have that so I can get some advice (the only problem is I won't be talking to north american catholic college students). The movie that serves as the "video presentation" that is being advertised is called "Punto y Aparte" ("Point and Apart"...? I dunno) which I haven't seen (I've been given a copy and I'm going to watch it this afternoon). It's apparently a Mexican film that tells the story of two sexually teenage active couples that get pregnant, one rich and one poor. So in the next (less than) two weeks, I've gotta watch this movie and figure out what the heck I can say for an hour that will somehow accurately inform a bunch of families and youth about their sexual choices without getting me kicked out of the church. ANY ADVICE IS WELCOME! In the meantime, I probably won't be going out much, since I'm pretty sure there aren't too many other white, 20s-ish looking males with brown hair and goatees in the neighborhood...
Thursday, May 14, 2009
dos cosas
2. In a blog entry from way back when, I talked about a pie graph that's sort of like an unauthorized version of what Peru's take on the ol' USDA food guide pyramid would look like. This picture is painted on the wall of the kitchen of Kilometer 13 church. It explains why I eat so much rice and potatoes and so few vegetables. I recently took a photo just to prove I didn't make it up. Check it out.
Tuesday, May 12, 2009
A Burial
Duki was a German Shepard that was 10 years old that lived on the roof of our house (this is not abnormal -- roofs in Lima are used for two things mainly -- it's where people hang their clothes out to dry and keep their dogs). Duki had an allergy to fleas, and with just one flea bite he would break out with skin rashes. Duki also had osteoporosis. On top of that, the medication he was given to fight the flea allergy was becoming less and less effective over time. Roberto spent lots of time washing Duki and putting medicine to alleviate his skin rashes. Finally, as everything was becoming more and more expensive, and Duki was suffering more and more, the family made the hard decision to put him to sleep.
So yesterday I helped Roberto dig a hole in the "back yard," which is really a patio area between the house and the houses in back and on either side (all houses are packed together very tightly). There, we laid Duki to rest.
I didn't have a particularly close relationship with Duki. I played with him some every time I went to hang my clothes up to dry. But not too much, because even though he loved to run around and play, it was terrible for his osteoporosis. Aside from that, he never really liked for me to pet/cuddle him much. I was mainly sad for Roberto and the rest of the family, who really did lose a "family member" -- they treated Duki much better than a lot of dogs around here are treated.
During lunch, Roberto (who's Catholic/not religious) and Javier (who's a member of Santa Isabel church, so he's Christian/evangelical) had a discussion about whether dogs go to heaven. They asked me what I thought. I said I hoped so, but I that I didn't know, mainly because I didn't really know of biblical evidence that suggested an answer one way or another. And any time you have an eschatological discussion from Javier, it's going to be based totally on the bible.
A Birth
Last Thursday, Raquel came home from work early. She had evidently been having deep stomach pains since early that morning. As they became more intense, she realized that they were actually contractions. She came home with Melanie, a friend from her work, right after the family and I had finished eating lunch. As Javier was on his way out the door to return to work, he instructed me to go with her to the hospital. So at 2pm, Melanie and I left with Raquel to take her to the "Seguro" Hospital in nearby Comas. After examining her, the doctor instructed Raquel to go back home, do some walking, and return at 5:.
We did just that, all the while her pains getting stronger and stronger. Luckily, Keli, Javier's sister-in-law, and Blanca, Javier's mother were both home. Both being mothers, they helped Raquel calm down and helped her with the process. At about 4:15, Raquel really couldn't stand it any longer, so I went out, hailed a taxi and took her to the hospital (just the two of us this time). This time, she was admitted. And I was left in the waiting room.
Soon, Raquel's family arrived, and so did Javier as soon as he could leave from work. However, no one was allowed to go see/be with Raquel. No one. Not even Javier. Instead, we were instructed to go out and buy a couple things that the baby would need that weren't in the bag that we packed for Raquel in the hospital -- a different kind of soap and some special diapers. That's just the way things work at a public hospital in Comas. There also wasn't anybody who could definitively tell us how things were going. The hospital was simply too understaffed and under-resourced to operate effectively in such a poor, fast-growing area.
We were waiting in the same waiting area used for the emergency room. It was extremely crowded, with people standing around everywhere. None of them had serious injuries - they were mostly family members of patients, I think. But twice we did see someone burst through the hospital doors, crying hysterically after learning that a family member had passed away.
The initial, rough prognosis when Raquel and I arrived was that she would probably have the baby some time around midnight. At around 10pm, we (me, Javier and Raquel's sister, brother-in-law and niece) left to go eat dinner at a restaurant near the hospital. But having had the experience of waiting for so long and being frustrated over the lack of information at the hospital, we decided just to go home after finishing our meal. We knew going back would just mean more waiting, since no one "in charge" knew anything or was going to let us go visit Raquel anyway. We had also been assured that someone would call Javier when the baby was born to let us know. Javier decided that regardless, phone call or no phone call, he would go back to the hospital at 5am the next morning (when it would presumably be a lot less busy). I offered to go with him, and he told me he would wake me up so we could both go.
At 7:30 the next morning (Friday), I woke up naturally. Confused, I went to Javier's room, thinking he probably overslept (pretty silly in hindsight -- I'm sure he wouldn't have been able to sleep at ALL, looking back on it). It turns out at about 12:45am, the hospital called to tell him the baby had been born, and that both baby and mother were doing just fine. He had then gone BACK to the hospital with Keli and Raquel's family members (I was already asleep, so he didn't wake me up) only to be told once again that he wasn't allowed to go up and see his wife/new son. The reason we were given over and over again for being denied admittance was that the patient area upstairs was a "clean" area and they couldn't let people who weren't patients go in and contaminate it.
So even though no one had actually seen or talked to Raquel and we just had to take the hospital's word for it, we were all very relieved to learn that Raquel and baby Rodrigo were fine.
At 2pm that afternoon Javier, Blanca, Keli, Roberto (Javier's brother), Manuelito (Roberto & Keli's 9 month old baby) and I ALL went to the hospital during its "Official Visitation Hour" from 2-3pm, according to what Javier had just learned the night before. Raquel's family was already there when we arrived. We were all sure the hospital would probably only let us go in one at a time to visit, but decided to give it a shot. Of course, the hospital was too crowded, so all of us were once again denied entry.
So after that, I left to go spend some time with a few of the other YAVs in Lima for the rest of the night. The next day (Saturday), I learned that Javier and Raquel's family had stayed waiting at the hospital, and FINALLY late that afternoon they were allowed one by one to go visit with Raquel and Rodrigo. It was only then that we learned that Raquel had actually given birth at 6pm on Thursday -- just a little more than an hour after I got her to the hospital -- and not at 12:30 that night like we originally thought. Because Rodrigo was born a couple weeks premature, he had an irregular heartbeat and couldn't come home right away. He was kept for observation. Raquel came home that afternoon, but went back to the hospital that night to nurse the baby. On Sunday, she did the same thing, going back and forth. And yesterday, Monday, FINALLY Rodrigo was cleared to come home and I was able to see him for myself (still too terrified to hold him though...) He's adorable. Pictures will come soon.
Monday, May 11, 2009
Poverty
I’ve had one particular pair of khaki pants since high school. I bought them from Target. A couple of years ago, I wore them while painting a banner. Ever since, there’s been a small black paint stain on one side. Other than that, they’re a perfectly decent pair of pants. Before coming to Peru, I went through stages where at times I was self-conscious of wearing clothes that appeared stained or worn-out, while at other times I flaunted the artsy, “I don’t give a damn” look of wearing whatever was comfortable.
While packing to leave the
While among many people living in conditions of extreme poverty, that attitude may indeed be prevalent, I have a feeling that anyone who’s ever spent a considerable amount of time working with the urban poor is probably laughing at my earlier logic. Even though there have been many days when no one seems to notice the pants, quite frequently when I wear them people tend to point out the stain. “What happened?” they ask sympathetically, assuming that I accidentally stained the paints earlier in the day and hadn’t had a chance to change. Or they try to be helpful: “Did you know there’s a stain there?” Many people don’t understand why I would wear a stained pair of pants.
So what’s the point in telling you all this? The point is, as it turns out, appearances matter. A lot. Many of the kids who attend the Compassion program at Kilometer 13 church wear pretty nice clothes. Some don’t. But many wear clothes that appear to be new and de marca (“name brand”). Several of the older kids (13-16) years old) also have relatively fancy cell phones. For birthdays and Christmas, nice clothes are probably the most popular gift. Yet, as I’ve described in my first
This reality obviously has many nuances that are unique to Peru, which I’ll hopefully get to describe in detail in a later entry. But in many ways, it’s not too different from what poverty looks like in large US cities. And most people reading this probably are already well aware that “poor people have nice cell phones and wear name brand clothes.”
To us well-meaning, soft-hearted, white, middle-upper class do-gooders and our “never ever blame the victim” mindsets, this is the type of poverty that frustrates us, pains us and baffles us. The painful, baffling frustration is perhaps epitomized by something that pastor Hernando of KM 13 church shared with me last weekend. He recently visited the home of a family with children who are enrolled in the compassion program. During the visit, discovered that they have cable TV. At a parents’ meeting for Compassion a few days later, these particular parents complained that it was hard to pay the 2 soles (about 70 cents) per week requested to help pay the small salaries received by the cooks and tutors that work at Compassion. “Right then I realized,” Hernando said to me “that a lot of the families with children who attend Compassion aren’t really poor. This is a problem.”
Since Hernando always harps to other people about me being a “professional” sociologist, I seized this opportunity to talk about what I think causes this issue. Deciding to ignore the fact that the family could easily be "borrowing" their cable from a neighbor, I explained to him the sociological concept of “symbolic capital.” Cell phones, name-brand clothes and cable TV are examples of symbolic capital. You don’t generally associate these things with poverty. And that is EXACTLY the reason that poor people have them. They’re symbols of wealth. They’re signposts of success. No one, except for me and my fellow “Irresistible Revolution”-ary, (formerly) middle-upper class white liberal Christian friends, is proud of being poor. Being impoverished is shameful. Everyone wants nice things for their families, especially their children. In our world, people left and right are seemingly pulling themselves up by their own bootstraps (or at least talking about how they did earlier in life, or about how their parents did, or how their grandparents did). This creates a culture where blaming the victim is exactly what we do. “Anyone can make it with hard work in America” proclaims the American Dream. The obvious corollary to this rule is “so if you don’t ‘make it,’ you obviously aren’t a hard worker.” Or “if you don’t make it, you’re not as good of a person as the rest of us, who have achieved success.” So to hide this shameful “failure,” people use what money they DO have to buy the appearance of success.
In my opinion, to really be able to “dig yourself out” of poverty, you have to be frugal and scrounge to get by on minimum necessities. That way, you can save whatever might be left over to invest in “real” capital – materials to start your own business or create some other income gaining/saving technique. But the downside to this is that because you’re only spending a minimum amount of money on just buying the basics, from the outside you tend to look rather ummmm, poor. "Low class." So instead, many people in conditions of poverty use their money to buy the "luxuries" they should only be able to afford AFTER becoming successful. Or to put it in fancy “I’m 22 and have a bachelor’s degree” language, they invest in symbolic capital rather than economic capital.
